BANGKOK – A mix of unscrupulous traffickers, Burma’s economic decline and militarisation, and a shortage of males caused by China’s one-child policy contribute to the trafficking of women from the Palaung region of Burma into China, says a locally-based activist group.
“Since 2007 we documented 72 cases of actual and suspected trafficking involving 110 people” said Lway Moe Kam of the Palaung Women’s Organisation (PWO), adding that her research showed that 11 children under ten years of age were among the victims.
25% of the women trafficked were forced to marry Chinese men and 10% of the caseload were coerced into the sex trade, according to the PWO, which grimly concluded that 90% of trafficking victims do not escape.
One particularly gruesome account was given by a woman who said that she was taken to a building in Shandong, eastern China, where people were kept as live feed for leeches, which are used in Chinese medicine. “I saw some people in that room in pools of water. They were all fat, but looked lifeless and were not moving. Then I saw that there were leeches sucking those people’s blood”, said the unnamed woman.
The PWO concedes that the number of trafficking victims is likely to be higher than reported, with real figures difficult to determine due to local cultural constraints, further hampered by the logistical and security challenges confronting researchers working in the area. In 60% of the cases analysed, it remained unclear exactly what situation the victim was trafficked into.
“Traffickers work in secret and the presence of the army means that we have to be careful when doing research and talking to people”, said Lway Aye Nang, another PWO representative. Palaung culture frowns upon extra-marital sex, meaning that trafficked women who suffered sexual crimes “are often reluctant to admit they have been trafficked”, added Lway Moe Kah, lead author of the PWO report Stolen Lives – Human Trafficking from Palaung Areas of Burma into China.
In perhaps a surprising finding, 65% of the trafficking perpetrators were female, a factor that Lway Moe Kam put down to the greater trust placed in women by the eventual victim of trafficking. “It sounds better if the job offer is made by a woman”, she said, though Khin Ohmar, a Burmese exile activist based in Chiang Mai, cautioned that the female perpetrators might themselves be coerced into recruitment by other traffickers, likely male, who dominate the trade.
The investigation focused on the townships of Namkahn, Namhsan and Mantong in the Palaung region of Shan State, which sits on the Burma-China frontier. In the absence of recent census date, the Palaung are thought to number around one million people, mostly mountain-dwellers in an area laden with gold, silver, zinc and aluminum.
China’s one child policy has contributed to a relative scarcity of women in the country, with the Chinese Academy of Social Sciences recently predicting that 24 million Chinese men of marrying age could be unable to find a wife by 2020. While the laws are not as aggressively-imposed in rural areas close to Burma as they are in China’s eastern seaboard cities, they contribute to a growing gender imbalance, with sex-selection abortions “extremely common”, according to the Academy. With families restricted by law to one, or perhaps two children, a cultural preference for male offspring has been exacerbated, said the Chinese researchers, resulting in 119 boys born for every 100 girls, a disparity that rises to 130-100 in some rural areas.
According to United States Government, in its 2010 report on global human trafficking trends, Burma’s Government has been working to combat some aspects of trafficking, such as the international sex trade. Burma prohibits sex and labor trafficking through its 2005 Anti-Trafficking in Persons Law, in which traffickers are classed in the same category as rapists. However the US report said that Burma’s internal trafficking situation had worsened, mentioning the use of child soldiers and forced labour by the army, abuses that are particularly common in ethnic minority areas.
However, the law is not applied on the ground, according to Palaung researchers, and Burma’s policy in other areas directly or indirectly contributes to the trafficking of women and children, they say, with conflict and economic decline forcing people to migrate, making them vulnerable to traffickers and criminal gangs.
Within Burma, the Palaung are perhaps best-known for the local tea industry. However in recent years this has been commandeered by the Burmese Army, which the PWO says has contributed to the human trafficking problem in the region.
The PWO accuses the Burmese Army of monopolising the tea industry, and of “forcing local people to sell their tea to military-supported companies at very low prices”. The ensuing income drop contributed to increased economic migration within Shan State and across the border to China, which renders local women vulnerable to traffickers.
Describing a similar scenario in Burma’s now conflict-wracked Kachin State, Khaung Seng Pan of the Kachin Women’s Association – Thailand (KWAT) says that “a lack of jobs and the army’s presence has pushed people out”. Her organisation says that it is aware of 130 cases of human trafficking into China from Burma since 2010, involving women and children from Kachin State.
Kachin State sits north of the Palaung region in Shan State, similarly sharing a border with China. Since June 9, the Kachin Independence Army (KIA) and the Burmese Army have fought on-off battles, with the KIA accusing the Government of breaching a long-standing ceasefire agreement and of engaging in encroachment into KIA-held areas. The Burmese Government is demanding that the KIA and other ethnic militias become part of the country’s border guard, which most of the militias have refused to do.